Launch your online business with artificial intelligence and start making money today with iCHAIT.COM

Suzane von Richthofen suffers a setback in attempt to change her uncle’s death certificate

Date:


Suzane von Richthofen’s request for an interim order was denied by a court in São Paulo amid a dispute over the inheritance of her uncle, physician Miguel Abdalla Netto, who died on January 9 of this year. According to information reported by Metrópoles, Suzane’s defense asked to amend his death certificate, which states that he was in a stable union with Carmem Silva Gonzalez Magnani.

Suzane was appointed administrator of the assets left by her uncle. She disputes whether Miguel and Carmem were in a relationship at the time of his death. The inventory process—the court proceeding through which a deceased person’s assets are identified and handled—remains suspended while a separate case considers whether the relationship should be legally recognized as a stable union.

The request was reviewed by Judge Rafael Saviano Pirozzi of the 12th Civil Court of Santo Amaro. He followed the position taken by the São Paulo State Public Prosecutor’s Office, which opposed changing the document before the circumstances of the relationship had been clarified.

Suzane’s lawyers sought to add a note to the death certificate saying that the claimed stable union was being challenged in court. They also intended to seek the permanent removal of the information once the separate case had concluded. The judge did not grant that request at this stage.

A death certificate is an official civil record of a person’s death and related information. In this case, the dispute concerns the entry about Miguel’s relationship with Carmem. The court’s decision addressed whether that entry could be altered or qualified while the underlying disagreement was still being considered. It did not resolve the separate question of whether the relationship qualifies as a stable union.

The distinction between the two proceedings is important. The case over recognition of the relationship concerns the status of Miguel and Carmem’s relationship. The inheritance inventory concerns the handling of assets left after his death. According to the report, the inventory is on hold while the court considers the relationship issue in another proceeding.

The documents cited by Suzane’s defense included statements Carmem made to police. On January 10, one day after Miguel’s death, she described herself as his “former partner and cousin” while seeking the release of his body. In February, she said that she “has not yet been recognized as Miguel’s partner.”

Carmem also reportedly said that she had not been in telephone contact with Miguel since the end of 2023. She stated that she had last been at his residence in January 2024, and that she did not enter the property. In a separate court case, she said the relationship took place from November 2011 through May 2015.

Those statements were presented by the defense as relevant to the question of whether the relationship was ongoing when Miguel died. They do not, by themselves, settle the legal issue. The accounts and dates are part of the material to be considered in the proceedings, and the court has not made a final determination on recognition of the relationship.

In denying the request, Pirozzi said the information submitted by the defense was not sufficient to justify changing the certificate, particularly because Carmem had not yet presented her defense in the case. “The likelihood of the right asserted has not been sufficiently demonstrated,” the judge wrote.

The judge acknowledged that the records point to a possible discrepancy between the reported end of the relationship and the date of Miguel’s death. He said, however, that those records alone did not justify changing the death record or adding the requested note at that point in the process, before both sides had had an opportunity to participate.

That reasoning reflects the limited nature of the request before the court. Suzane’s defense was seeking an interim change while the dispute remained unresolved. The judge’s decision left the existing entry in place for now and allowed the broader process to continue. It did not determine that Carmem’s account was correct, nor did it rule that Suzane’s position was incorrect.

A preliminary or interim request is considered before a court reaches a final decision on the underlying dispute. In this instance, the judge considered whether the available documents justified an immediate change to the certificate. His ruling focused on the timing and sufficiency of the material presented, as well as the fact that Carmem had not yet filed her response. The case over the relationship’s recognition remains separate and unresolved.

The decision also means the requested annotation will not be added while the court considers the matter further. The defense’s stated objective was to record that the stable union was being challenged and later seek the removal of the information. The court’s refusal to grant interim relief does not itself determine whether either of those steps may be considered after the proceedings develop.

The inheritance dispute comes as Suzane has also been named in the will of her paternal grandmother, Margot, the mother of Manfred von Richthofen. According to journalist and biographer Ullisses Campbell, Margot left Suzane an apartment valued at 1 million Brazilian reais, or approximately $185,000. The conversion is an estimate using an exchange rate of about 5.40 reais per U.S. dollar; the reported value of the apartment was given in Brazilian currency.

The dispute over Miguel’s assets followed the recent release of a Netflix documentary about Suzane. The production addresses the 2002 killings of her parents, Manfred and Marísia von Richthofen, as well as her life after serving part of her sentence and moving to an open prison regime. The documentary’s release is separate from the court proceedings over the death certificate, the alleged stable union and the inheritance.

For now, the court has not altered Miguel’s death certificate, and the inventory of his assets remains suspended while the separate case proceeds. The judge’s ruling leaves the central question—whether Miguel and Carmem’s relationship should be recognized as a stable union—to be addressed through that ongoing legal process.

Share post:

Subscribe

Popular

More like this
Related